2021年1月25日月曜日

陰謀論者を嘲笑しても、孤立感を深めて、意固地になるだけ。

 

The most effective ways to support a loved one who believes in QAnon

BY REBECCA RUIZ

SEP 30, 2020

Conspiracy theories appear to thrive at times of great uncertainty, which may help explain why your friend or family member has devoted much of their time and energy to QAnon in recent months.


Once down the rabbit hole, people will feel empowered to play a key role in a larger socio-political narrative.


"Any attempts to 'rescue' someone from QAnon have to be understood in these terms," said Dr. Pierre. "Those who have found meaning in QAnon don’t want to be rescued — they've finally found something that’s bigger than themselves. That's not going to be easily relinquished." 


 なるほどね。陰謀論ってのは、不確実、不安定な時代に栄える・・・コロナだからこうした陰謀論にはまりやすい条件は整っているわけだね。他の視点からいうと精神的に不安定な人がはまりやすいのかもしれない。今回、新興宗教系の人がハマったのも合点がいく。

 陰謀論の仲間たちのなかで自分になかった力を感じたり、意味を見出していくわけだね。


The QAnon cult: What it is, how it works, and how to help deprogram your loved ones


Annie Reneau01.19.21


It doesn't matter that specific Q prophecies don't come true. Adherents just keep saying, "Trust the plan," even though the plan isn't clear. It's a test of faith. They also come up with ways to explain away facts that counter the belief.


This is what's the most bafflingly frustrating thing about trying to reason with a QAnoner. You just can't. It doesn't matter how many facts you bring in or logical inconsistencies you point out. "The lengths to which a true believer will contort the truth or manufacture evidence really can't be overstated," say Infranaut.


So how do we get people out? The key hurdle is people's inability to accept and admit that they were wrong. Infranaut calls "the beating heart" of the QAnon movement is the idea of "I didn't get duped." No one wants to believe they voted for a conman, or that they supported a sexual predator, or that they are still waiting around for him to save the world.

事実を提示したり不整合を指摘しても事実を捻じ曲げたり、証拠を捏造したりして整合性を保持しようとするから、そんなことをしても無駄。 

suzukyさんがリツイート


YOUNG: Do not mock. Do not use snark. All of the, you know, Twitter posts where people make fun of the crazy QAnon supporters, all that does is further reinforce their sense that they are disrespected and maligned. No. 2 - using scientific evidence, argumentation, etc., that comes through the very institutions that they have been told not to trust, that is going to backfire because now they think that you are the dupe because you trust these institutions, etc.


CORNISH: Young says it's smart to acknowledge that the world does feel pretty crazy right now, and all of us are a little confused. And her main do is pretty straightforward.


YOUNG: Come at them with unconditional love, as hard as that is, reminding them of the preexisting bonds that you have. If it's a brother or sister, how about talking about old stories and just texting them and saying, oh, my gosh, I remembered that fishing trip that we had back when we were 5 and you fell in the lake, right? Because now you're asking them to tap into an identity that they haven't tapped into in a while, and that is their identity as a brother or a sister.

 馬鹿にしない、科学的議論をしない、無条件の愛で受け入れる。相手が家族だとすれば、昔話に花を咲かせて自分たちの親密な関係を再確認したりする・・・・ 

・・・・・愛だな。


 
でも聞いて寝ようっと。

0 件のコメント:

コメントを投稿