チンコ付きのトランス女性が女性スペース入場禁止ならなんのためのLGBT法案なのか？

buvery Retweeted

常識的で穏当なトランス女性活動家の主張が、すべてのトランス当事者の主張とは一致していない。

だからこそ、すでに日本でも女湯・女子トイレに侵入して自撮りしSNSに投稿している過激な当事者がいる。

「性自認」による「差別禁止」を謳うなら、女性の危惧するところを解消する内容にするべき。

— 冨田格（いたる） (@itaru1964) March 18, 2023

　性同一性障害で性器も戸籍も女性になった人が女性スペースに入ることに問題はない。

　チンコ付きのトランス女性が女性スペース入場禁止ならなんのためのLGBT法案なのか？　LGBT法案はTraonswoman is a woman の掛け声のもと女性専用スペースにトランス女性が入っても違法でないようにする法案じゃないのけ？

Apply for a Gender Recognition Certificate

Having a certificate means you can:

update your birth or adoption certificate, if it was registered in the UK

get married or form a civil partnership in your affirmed gender

update your marriage or civil partnership certificate, if it was registered in the UK

have your affirmed gender on your death certificate when you die

  Changing gender to be made easier in Scotland

Published

23 December 2022

The new rules, which are expected to come into force sometime next year, will mean applicants will now only need to have lived in their acquired gender for three months - or six months if they are aged 16 and 17 - rather than two years.

There will be also be a three-month "reflection period" during which they can change their minds and it will be a criminal offence to make a false declaration or false application for a GRC, with anyone who does so potentially facing up to two years in prison.

It will be possible to de-transition by going through the process again.

スコットランドでは、3ヶ月女性として暮らしてそれで本人がよければ、公式に女性になれる、と。

BBC

Spain approves divisive transgender bill Published 22 December 2022 

 "Trans women are women," said Ms Montero, who has strongly advocated for gender self-identification and criticised opposition to the law as "transphobia".

Critics say the law will be open to abuse and could threaten women's rights, allowing men who self-identify as women to compete in women's sports or request transfers to women's prisons. They have also raised concern about minors having the right to self-determine their gender.

The guardian 

Spain passes law allowing anyone over 16 to change registered gender

The new transgender law – which was passed despite protests from feminist groups, warnings from opposition parties, and amid tensions between different wings of the Socialist-led coalition government – means that anyone aged over 16 will be able to change their gender on official documents without medical supervision

スペインでも同様な法律が成立したが、スポーツ競技や女性監獄などで混乱があるのではないか、という意見も。

buveryさんがリツイートしました

【スペインの終焉】トランス法が成立、性転換手術なしで誰でも性別変更可能に　トランス女性に女子更衣室などの利用を拒むと最大15万ユーロ（約2125万）の罰金　男性の申請者が殺到 | RAPT理論+α https://t.co/9gxgxGdDhi

— 奥田幸雄 (@yukiookuda) March 18, 2023

The Objective 

 'Trans law': fines of 150,000 euros if transgender people are denied access to changing rooms

The rule also severely punishes the dissemination in schools of textbooks and teaching materials that can be considered as "transphobic"

wiki

  The Objective  The Objective is a Spanish digital newspaper exempt from subscription

LGBT法案というのは当然、そっちの方向に向かう法律である。

おれはそれが悪いとも思わない。ただ、自認だけでいい、というのは問題あり、というのが私見。

いずれにせよ、日本では議論不足。

LGBT推進論者も議論が定まっていない。